I have decided to separate my HTPC and NAS. I decided to go for a low cost, low power NAS solution. Possible options I considered:
- DroboPro with iSCSI
- Pros: 8 disk bays, iSCSI, ability add to different drive sizes
- Cons: $$$ Locked-in, Expensive for barebones box: $1500
- QNAP TS-419
- Pros: 4 disk bay, iSCSI, exapandability, NAS, CIFS, TimeMachine,etc
- Cons: $$ Locked-in, Expensive for barebones box: $600
- Iomega StorCenter ix4-200d
- Pros: Disks included, iSCSI, Time Machine support
- Cons: $$ Cannot install larger drives, Expensive for barebones box: $899
- DIY box:
- Pros: Flexibility, FreeNAS, ZFS for snapshots.
- Cons: Cheaper but limitations based on supported hardware. $800+
After a long analysis for a few months, here is hardware I came up with: Intel SS-4200 with 4 SATA, 512 MB memory. I am planning to install FreeNAS on it as it has ZFS support. ZFS has advantages of snapshots, growth, iSCSI, etc. Plus, it was important to get a low cost, low power consumption machine as it would be running all the time. The SS-4200 has 4 disk bay, low power Celeron, onboard 120 MB DOM (Disk On Module), 1 Gb NIC, USB and eSATA ports for expansion.
Here is the part list: